Articles
of incorporation for a C corporation are known as articles of organization for
an LLC,( Limited Liability Company). The bylaws of a C corporation have
their equivalent in the operating agreement of an LLC (neither of which is filed
with the Secretary of State as a matter of public record). An LLC may be
run by a manager or managers, equivalent to a C corporation’s director(s). Alternatively,
it may be run by its members, which would make it most similar to an S corporation
(a C corporation that elects S corporation status), allowing for profits to flow
through to the members.
In
many ways the LLC had been an awkward corporate form and we have seen little to
no advantage in going with an LLC over a C corporation. In some cases where
two or more corporations might work together on a specific project of a limited
duration, an LLC has been used basically as the agreement between the cooperating
parties—but why not just have an agreement? As a consequence, we have been
involved in the establishment of thousands of C corporations but only a small
handful of LLCs, up ’until now.
There
are certain key amendments in SB51
, however, that stand to make the LLC a much more useful corporate form.
One of the changes would create something called a “noneconomic member”
of an LLC, a “person” (natural or corporate) who owns nothing but could control
everything. Here is how it is defined:
Sec.
38. “Noneconomic member” means a member of a limited-liability company
who:
1.
Does not own a member’s interest in the company;
2. Does not have an obligation
to contribute capital to the company;
3. Does not have a right to participate
in or receive distributions of profits of the company or an obligation to contribute
to the losses of the company; and
4. May have voting rights and other rights
and privileges given to noneconomic members of the company by the articles of
organization or operating agreement.
Put more succinctly:
A “noneconomic member” may have control without ownership.
One
of the keys to understanding the power of this provision is in the last 3 words:
“or operating agreement”. Keep in mind that the operating agreement is not a matter
of public record. This means that from the OUTSIDE, a “noneconomic member”
could be indistinguishable from any other member of the LLC and thus may avail
himself of PRIVACY in exercising control over the LLC.
Let’s back up a little
and consider how this provision might apply to the two variations of LLCs—in the
first case, whereby it is run by a manager or managers; and in the second case,
used mainly as a partnership, whereby it is run by its members.
Let’s say
NV ACQUISITIONS, LLC lists as its manager NV MANAGEMENT, INC. and that it operates
as and is taxed as a corporation. Who owns NVA, LLC? Presumably, it
is owned by its members. But its members are NOT on the public record.
Who
controls NVA, LLC? Presumably, and this is all anyone may know in viewing this
situation from the outside, control rests with NVM, INC. But what if NVM, INC.
serves in its capacity under the control of an unlisted “noneconomic member”?
NVM, INC. could be replaced as the manager at any time—by the “noneconomic member”
with voting rights—perhaps even shortly after the annual list for NVA, LLC is
filed.
Make a demand of NVM, INC. and it might reply that it no longer
has anything to do with NVA, LLC, having had its responsibilities terminated at
the direction of the “noneconomic member”. Make a demand of NVA, LLC and
you are dealing only with a corporate “person”, with no way of knowing what natural
persons are involved. All the while, the “noneconomic member” remains in
complete control from behind the scenes. Can you see what a shell game can
be established here? In essence, the corporate “person” of NVM, INC. takes
on the role of the nominee used to ensure privacy in C corporations.
Let’s
look at the second variation: an LLC run by its members. The members of an LLC
could be any natural or corporate persons—even LLCs themselves. Who owns,
say, NVB, LLC, in a case where a “noneconomic member” is involved? If the members
are, say, NVC, NVD and NVE—is there any way of knowing which of these three, IF
ANY, is a “noneconomic member”? Perhaps they ALL are? There simply is no
way to know from the public records since a “noneconomic member” may be designated
as such within the operating agreement for the LLC, which is not a matter of public
record. As you can see, the provision creating a “noneconomic member” makes it
impossible to determine the ownership of an LLC—from the outside.
Who controls
NVB, LLC? Is there any way to know, from the outside, whether NVC, NVD or NVE
hold any voting rights? Not if “noneconomic member” status is spelled out
in the (non-public) operating agreement as opposed to the (publicly filed) articles
of organization.
Either way, there is obvious potential for privacy of ownership
and control of an LLC availing itself of the new “noneconomic member” provision
in SB 51. When combined with the new provisions spelled out in Section
41 of SB 51 (which allow for an LLC to create and define different classes
of members or managers with different voting rights) Nevada LLCs appear to be
taking on all of the most desirable characteristics of C corporations—and taking
them even further.
If our interpretation is not too far off the mark, we
would expect to see a great many new LLCs formed using the first, non-flow-through
variation, with a corporate “person” as the manager—and “noneconomic members”
in common usage. Where the need for privacy is greatest, no doubt there
will be many “layered” variations in strategic applications: LLCs established
for privacy, with members also established for privacy. If each entity that is
a "partner" in the LLC is a properly formed Nevada Corporation, with
privacy, this tool can be an added layer of protection for all parties in the
joint venture.
If this seems confusing even when it is spelled out like
this—perhaps that is what was intended by those who introduced this legislation?
The bottom line seems to be that the potential for privacy, even at the expense
of a little more complexity, is being greatly enhanced.
How
is an LLC managed?
An LLC may be managed by its members (owners)
or by selected managers. If the LLC is to be managed by its members, it operates
much like a partnership. Each member has an equal say in the decision making process
of the company. If the members choose, they may elect a manager or managers to
act in a capacity similar to a corporation's board of directors. These managers
are in charge of the affairs of the corporation. Member management is the normal
default rule of state law. This means that if managers are not selected in the
articles of organization the members will direct the affairs of the LLC.
Taxation
of LLCs
One owner LLCs are treated the same as sole
proprietorships. Profits are reported on Schedule C as part of your individual
1040 tax return. Self-employment taxes on LLC net income must be paid just as
you would with any self-employment business. Multiple owner LLCs are treated as
a partnership by the IRS. The tax return that the LLC completes and files is IRS
Form 1065, Partnership Information Return. On this form, LLC profits are reported
and allocated to each of the owners according to the LLC's operating agreement.
Each owner is given a Schedule K-1, which shows each owner's share of LLC income
or loss. The owner then reports and pays taxes on this income on the owner's annual
1040 income tax return. Please note that as with a sole proprietorship, all profits
of the LLC are taxed to the owners, even if they are not actually distributed
by the LLC. This situation could happen when the LLC needs to use its profits
to meet ongoing expenses. There is a possible third tax treatment that an LLC
could elect if it did not want pass-through taxation. The LLC may elect to be
taxed as a corporation by completing IRS Form 8832 and checking the corporate
income tax treatment box. After making this election, the LLC is taxed as a C
corporation by the federal government unless the LLC files a form 2253 and is
taxed as an S Corporation. The state income tax treatment of LLC profits typically
mirrors the IRS tax treatment as discussed above. Some states have different rules
and for specific information on your state rules visit your state's web site.
The web addresses can be found on our state links
information page. *California LLCs are subject to a annual minimum franchise tax
of $800 per year. The first payment must be made within 3 months of formation.
What are the advantages of
an LLC?
LLCs offer numerous advantages. Pass-Through
Taxation LLCs allow for pass-through taxation. This means that earnings of an
LLC are taxed only once. The earnings of an LLC may be treated like the earnings
from a partnership, sole proprietorships and most S corporations.
Limited Liability and Charging Order Protections. The LLC owner's liability
is generally limited to the amount of money which the person has invested in the
LLC. Thus, LLC members are offered the same limited liability protection as a
corporation's shareholders. Flexible Management Structure and Flexible Ownership
is Permitted Like general partnerships, LLCs are generally free to establish any
organizational structure agreed on by its members. Thus, profit interests may
be separated from voting interests.
Should
I choose an LLC or an S corporation?
While
the S corporation's special tax status eliminates double taxation, it lacks the
flexibility of an LLC in allocating income to the owners. An LLC may offer several
classes of membership interests while an S corporation may only have one class
of stock. Any number of individuals or entities may own interests in an LLC. However,
ownership interest in an S corporation is limited to no more than 75 shareholders.
Also, S corporations cannot be owned by C corporations, other S corporations,
many trusts, LLCs, partnerships or nonresident aliens. LLCs are allowed to have
subsidiaries without restriction. S corporations are not allowed to own eighty
percent or more of another corporation's shares.
Advantages
of a Limited Liability Company (LLC) over an S Corporation While the S corporations
limit their ownership to 75 persons, a Limited Liability Company has no limit
There are no restrictions regarding the character of members of the Limited Liability
Company Upon formation, tax-free transfers can be made to a Limited Liability
Company A Limited Liability Company can own 100% of the stock of another corporation,
where an S corporation cannot be a member of any affiliated group. Members of
a Limited Liability Company can get a basis increase for their share of the company’s
liabilities A member can step up his basis in his share of the Limited Liability
Company’s property to reflect his outside basis in membership interest
A
strategy now used by many is having an LLC that is taxed as an S Corporation.
You may have charging order liability protections and still have the S Corporation
tax advantages.
